By Candice Thompson CertRP, Head of Recruitment at Hunter Adams
We recently worked on a retained Group HR Manager vacancy that attracted more than 200 applications.
What made that particularly interesting wasn’t just the volume.
It was how many of those applicants could genuinely do the job.
There were plenty of people with credible HR backgrounds, relevant qualifications and experience at the appropriate level.
That creates a very different recruitment challenge from searching for one obviously qualified person in a small candidate pool.
When dozens of people meet the technical requirements, employers naturally start looking more closely at everything else.
How has this person made a difference in their previous organisations?
How will they work with this particular leadership team?
Do they understand our business?
Can they influence?
Will they fit the environment?
And sometimes the difference between being offered the job and receiving a rejection becomes incredibly small.
That is one of the realities HR candidates are navigating in 2026.
A rejection doesn’t always mean something went wrong
One of the hardest conversations we have with candidates at the moment is explaining that they weren’t unsuccessful because they performed badly.
Sometimes they gave an excellent interview.
Their experience was relevant. They communicated well. The hiring manager liked them.
Another candidate simply matched one very specific part of the brief more closely.
That can be difficult to hear, particularly when somebody has invested time preparing, interviewing and perhaps completing more than one stage of a process.
But in a crowded market, recruitment is not always a contest between a good candidate and a bad one.
It can be a decision between several very good people.
Understanding that matters because candidates can otherwise respond to rejection by assuming they need to completely reinvent themselves.
Often, they don’t.
What they do need is a clearer understanding of the value they bring and how to communicate it.
Experience tells me less when it is only a list
One of the biggest differences I see between candidates is how they talk about their experience.
There is a world of difference between saying:
“I was responsible for employee retention.”
and being able to explain:
- What the retention challenge was
- What you did about it
- Who you had to influence
- What changed
- What impact it had on the organisation
Employers increasingly want that second level of detail.
For senior HR professionals in particular, simply describing your remit is not enough.
Businesses want to understand the effect of your work.
That might mean being able to talk about:
- Cost savings you delivered
- Improvements in retention
- Reduced recruitment expenditure
- A major transformation project you led
- Employees redeployed during restructuring
- Roles protected
- Better use of an HR budget
- Improvements in team performance
- Workforce decisions you influenced using data
The strongest candidates connect HR activity to the organisation.
They don’t simply say what they did.
They explain why it mattered.
“Commercial” doesn’t mean becoming a finance director
We increasingly hear employers asking for HR candidates who are strategic and commercially minded.
Those words can become vague very quickly, so it is worth being clear about what employers tend to mean.
They want HR people who understand the wider business.
At senior level, that could mean being comfortable discussing budgets, understanding a profit and loss account and explaining the commercial implications of a people decision.
It also means being able to influence decisions before they are made rather than waiting for HR to be brought in afterwards.
A strong senior candidate might be able to describe a situation where they challenged a proposed decision, helped the leadership team understand its people implications and influenced a different outcome.
That’s commercial HR.
It is not about forgetting the people side of the profession.
It is about understanding that people decisions and business decisions are usually the same decisions viewed from different angles.
Fit becomes more important when capability is equal
There is another part of recruitment that is harder to quantify.
Chemistry.
If three candidates all have the technical capability required, the hiring manager starts asking who they can see themselves working closely with.
That does not mean hiring somebody because they are just like everyone else in the team.
Good recruitment should never be about creating a room full of identical personalities.
It means thinking about working style, communication, values and the relationships the role needs to build.
Some HR roles require considerable challenge and influence.
Others need somebody who can enter a difficult environment and build trust quickly.
A senior HR leader might need to work closely with a CEO, finance leader, operational directors and a wider HR team.
Those relationships matter.
A CV can establish whether somebody has done similar work before.
It can’t tell you how the working relationship will feel.
Small things become big differentiators
Candidates sometimes assume that only the formal interview answers matter.
They don’t.
First impressions happen throughout the process.
How you speak to the person arranging the interview matters.
How you communicate with the recruiter matters.
Your curiosity matters.
Listening matters.
Manners matter.
Even the small talk around the formal interview can tell somebody something about how you build relationships.
Preparation is another area where candidates can separate themselves.
I remember one candidate who realised they had heard the hiring manager speak at a conference several years earlier.
They remembered the presentation and referred to it thoughtfully during the process.
It was a small detail, but it demonstrated something important.
They had prepared properly. They were genuinely interested in the person and organisation in front of them, and they weren’t approaching the interview as just another generic opportunity.
You cannot manufacture that kind of connection through a standard interview script.
Your career does not need to be perfectly tidy
Another thing strong candidates tend to do well is talk honestly about their career history.
People experience redundancy.
They take time out.
They change direction.
They move into interim work.
They make choices that made sense at a particular stage of their life but might look less obvious on a CV several years later.
Trying to hide or over-explain those things can make a conversation unnecessarily difficult.
I’d much rather a candidate tell me the context.
If I understand what happened, I can represent them properly to the client.
A career doesn’t need to be completely linear to be credible.
But you do need to understand your own story. And I need to understand their story to paint a picture of them to the employer.
Why networking still matters
A competitive application market also makes professional relationships more important.
At senior level in particular, not every opportunity begins with an advert.
Sometimes it starts with a conversation.
That is why I encourage candidates to remain visible even when they are not actively applying.
Keep your LinkedIn profile current.
Attend industry events when you can.
Take part in relevant professional communities.
Stay in contact with recruiters you trust.
Talk to people.
Networking isn’t about asking strangers for jobs.
It is about having relationships in place before you need them.
That becomes incredibly valuable if you suddenly find yourself back in the market after ten or fifteen years in one organisation.
Employers need to be careful too
A large candidate pool can feel like a fantastic position for an employer.
And it can be.
But more choice can create its own problems.
When there are several credible candidates, organisations can become tempted to keep looking for an imaginary perfect person.
Processes stretch.
Another stakeholder gets added.
Decisions take longer.
Meanwhile, the strongest candidates continue having conversations elsewhere.
Being selective is sensible.
Allowing a recruitment process to drift is not.
The employer still needs to know which capabilities are essential, which would simply be useful and where there is room for somebody to learn.
Otherwise, a large applicant pool can make a decision harder rather than easier.
Know what makes you different
For candidates, the message I would take from today’s market is not “you need to be perfect”.
You don’t.
But you do need to know what impact you bring.
If ten people can perform the technical requirements of a role, what will the employer remember about you?
Perhaps it’s…
your experience of a very similar transformation.
the way you influenced a difficult leadership decision.
measurable commercial impact.
your ability to build relationships quickly.
the depth of your specialist expertise.
The answer will be different for every person.
Your job is to understand yours.
And then be able to explain it.
Related reading
Technology is also contributing to growing application volumes and changing the way candidates prepare for opportunities. In AI in recruitment: Why human judgement matters more than ever, I explore how AI is changing applications, screening and recruitment, and why technology still needs to sit alongside meaningful human judgement.
Looking for your next HR opportunity?
Our recruitment team supports HR professionals across permanent, FTC and interim opportunities throughout the UK.
You can view our latest vacancies through the Hunter Adams jobs board, or speak to the team about what you’re looking for next.
About Candice
Candice Thompson CertRP, Head of Recruitment
Candice has been part of Hunter Adams since 2013 and heads up our recruitment service across the UK.
She holds a Level 3 Certificate in Recruitment Practice (CertRP) from the Recruitment & Employment Confederation as well as an undergraduate degree in Social Psychology.
With more than 12 years at Hunter Adams and extensive experience recruiting HR professionals at all levels, Candice works closely with both candidates and employers to understand not just whether somebody can do a role, but whether the opportunity and organisation are right for them.